This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, My Cooking Era may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Recommendations include useful tools and optional kitchen treats. How we handle affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
An original practice recipe, not independently kitchen-tested. Times and yields are estimates. Read ingredient labels for allergens and follow appliance and package directions. Images are AI-generated editorial inspiration, not photographs of tested results.
You do not have to bake the cookie to enjoy decorating the cookie. This project gives you one manageable job: make a plain cookie feel festive.
Ingredients
- 12 chocolate sandwich cookies
- 8 ounces (225 g) chocolate candy melting wafers
- 2 ounces (55 g) orange or white candy melting wafers
- 24 edible candy eyes, or 24 mini chocolate chips for a contrasting pale coating
- 1 tablespoon sprinkles, optional
Method
- Line a tray with parchment and arrange your decorations. Choose a bowl deep enough to dip a cookie.
- Melt the chocolate coating following its package instructions. Stir often and keep the bowl and utensils dry.
- Place one cookie in the coating. Lift with a fork and let the excess drip back. Slide onto the lined tray with help from a spoon.
- Add two candy eyes while the surface is soft. Repeat with the remaining cookies. If dipping a whole cookie feels fiddly, dip only half and place the eyes on the coated side.
- Melt the orange or white coating separately. Drizzle thin lines with a spoon, leaving the eyes visible. Add sprinkles before the lines set.
- Let firm in a cool spot for about 25 minutes, or chill briefly until the coating is firm. Avoid stacking until completely set.
Three looks from one batch
Use a plain dark coat and two eyes for a peeking monster. Add orange stripes for a pumpkin-party cookie. Use white stripes across a dark cookie for a mummy-inspired face. The same ingredients can give you a whole cast of little characters.
Keep it comfortable
Set aside one cookie as your practice piece. Too much coating makes a bulky shell; let the excess drip for a few seconds. A tiny puddle underneath can be trimmed after setting, but it is also fine to leave it.
A cooling rack can help with other baking projects, but parchment is enough here. You do not need a special dipping machine or a piping kit.
Storage and allergen notes
Store fully set cookies in an airtight container, separated with parchment, in a cool room. Make them one day ahead for a party and aim to enjoy within three days for best texture. Refrigerate if your kitchen is warm; let the closed container approach room temperature before opening to reduce condensation. Shelf life has not been independently tested.
Cookies and coatings may contain wheat, milk, soy and other allergens. Check every ingredient label. Candy eyes and hard decorations are unsuitable for some young children.
For a project with even less precision, make monster bark. For a reminder that wobbly decorations count, read the Pinterest-fail pep talk.